Quick question on confidence intervals

**downthesun01** · Oct 9th 2010, 07:36 AM

Ten engineering schools in the US were surveyed. The sample contained 250 electrical engineers, 80 being women, and 175 chemical engineers, 40 being women. Compute a 90% confidence interval for the difference between the porportion of women in these two fields of engineering. Is there a significant difference between the two proportions?

I calculated the confidence interval and got:

$0.091+/-0.043$

I'm a bit stuck on answering the bolded part though.

I would say that there is a significant difference between the two proportions because the 90% confidence interval doesn't include 0.

Is this correct? Thanks

**CaptainBlack** · Oct 9th 2010, 10:13 PM

Originally Posted by downthesun01

Ten engineering schools in the US were surveyed. The sample contained 250 electrical engineers, 80 being women, and 175 chemical engineers, 40 being women. Compute a 90% confidence interval for the difference between the porportion of women in these two fields of engineering. Is there a significant difference between the two proportions?

I calculated the confidence interval and got:

$0.091+/-0.043$

I'm a bit stuck on answering the bolded part though.

I would say that there is a significant difference between the two proportions because the 90% confidence interval doesn't include 0.

Is this correct? Thanks

What did you get for the SE of the difference of the two proportions?

The 90% confidence interval is the observed difference +/- 1.645*SE

CB

**downthesun01** · Oct 9th 2010, 10:25 PM

$SE=\frac{0.043}{1.645}\approx 0.0261$

**CaptainBlack** · Oct 9th 2010, 10:42 PM

Originally Posted by downthesun01

$SE=\frac{0.043}{1.645}\approx 0.0261$

No, I know what its value is and how to calculate it, what I want to know is how you calculated it, or rather how you calculated the length of the confidence interval (it's a bit like a hint that I think that it is wrong).

CB

**downthesun01** · Oct 10th 2010, 09:12 AM

$\sqrt{\frac{(0.32)(0.68)}{250}+{\frac{(0.229)(0.77 1)}{175}}}=\sqrt{0.001879308571}\approx 0.043$

**CaptainBlack** · Oct 10th 2010, 08:31 PM

Originally Posted by downthesun01

$\sqrt{\frac{(0.32)(0.68)}{250}+{\frac{(0.229)(0.77 1)}{175}}}=\sqrt{0.001879308571}\approx 0.043$

The 90% confidence interval is the observed difference +/- 1.645*SE

So the confidence interval is: .... ?

CB

**downthesun01** · Oct 10th 2010, 08:51 PM

$pr(0.091-0.043<P_{a}-P_{b}<0.091+0.043)=0.9$

$pr(0.48<P_{a}-P_{b}<0.139)=0.9$

If there's something that you're trying to help me see, I'm totally not getting it sorry.

**CaptainBlack** · Oct 10th 2010, 10:22 PM

Originally Posted by downthesun01

$pr(0.091-0.043<P_{a}-P_{b}<0.091+0.043)=0.9$

$pr(0.48<P_{a}-P_{b}<0.139)=0.9$

If there's something that you're trying to help me see, I'm totally not getting it sorry.

Read what has been posted in this thread, we know what the observed difference Ob, is (0.091), we know what the standard error SE of this difference is (0.0433..) and we know the 90% confidence interval is [Ob-1.645.SE, Ob+1.645.SE], so ....

What I want you to see is that the confidence interval is:

$[0.091-1.645\times 0.0433, 0.091+1.645\times 0.0433]\approx [0.091-0.071,0.091+0.071]=[0.020,0.162]$

In other words I want you to calculate the confidence interval correctly.

CB

**downthesun01** · Oct 10th 2010, 11:15 PM

Oh. You're right. That's what I have written down on paper. Typing all this through my phone is a bit tedious. My mistake.

However, it still leaves me wondering the difference between the two proportions is significant. I'll just say yes. Thanks

**CaptainBlack** · Oct 10th 2010, 11:50 PM

Originally Posted by downthesun01

Oh. You're right. That's what I have written down on paper. Typing all this through my phone is a bit tedious. My mistake.

However, it still leaves me wondering the difference between the two proportions is significant. I'll just say yes. Thanks

Since zero is not in the confidence interval, the difference is significant at this level.

CB

Thread: Quick question on confidence intervals

LinkBack

Thread Tools

Display

Quick question on confidence intervals

Similar Math Help Forum Discussions

confidence intervals

confidence intervals question

Confidence Intervals

confidence intervals

Confidence Intervals

Search tags for this page

ten engineering schools in the us were surveyed. the sample contained 250 electrical engineers

ten engineering schools in the us were surveyed