# Thread: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

1. ## Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Show that $98^{76543} + 21$ is not divisible by $11$.

I do not know how to approach this.

2. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
Show that $98^{76543} + 21$ is not divisible by $11$.

I do not know how to approach this.
Hint :

$\begin{cases}98^n-1 \equiv 0 \pmod {11}, & \text{if }n\text{ is even} \\98^n-1 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}, & \text{if }n\text{ is odd}\end{cases}$

3. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Since $n = 76543$ is odd, so $98^{76543} - 1 \equiv 9 (mod 11)$. We also have $20 \equiv 9 (mod 11)$. Hence $98^{76543} - 1 - 20 \equiv 9 - 9 (mod 11)$ or $98^{76543} - 21 \equiv 0 (mod 11)$. Doesn't this mean that $98^{76543} - 21$ is divisible by $11$?

How would you work out the congruence relations you stated by yourself say in exam conditions?

4. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
Since $n = 76543$ is odd, so $98^{76543} - 1 \equiv 9 (mod 11)$. We also have $20 \equiv 9 (mod 11)$. Hence $98^{76543} - 1 - 20 \equiv 9 - 9 (mod 11)$ or $98^{76543} - 21 \equiv 0 (mod 11)$. Doesn't this mean that $98^{76543} - 21$ is divisible by $11$?

How would you work out the congruence relations you stated by yourself say in exam conditions?
You are correct but your question was :

$\text{Does}~11 \mid \left(98^{76543}+21\right) ?$

5. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Thanks! Sometimes I get really confused.

So $22 \equiv 0 (\mod 11)$ and add this to your congruence we get $98^{76543} - 1 + 22 \equiv 9 + 0 (\mod 11)$ which is $98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 9 (\mod 11)$.

But still, how do you know that $98^{n} -1 \equiv 9 (\mod 11)$ when $n$ is odd?

6. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
Thanks! Sometimes I get really confused.

So $22 \equiv 0 (\mod 11)$ and add this to your congruence we get $98^{76543} - 1 + 22 \equiv 9 + 0 (\mod 11)$ which is $98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 9 (\mod 11)$.

But still, how do you know that $98^{n} -1 \equiv 9 (\mod 11)$ when $n$ is odd?
$98^n-1=97 \cdot \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} 98^i$

Note that :

$97 \equiv 9 \pmod {11} ~\text{and}~\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} 98^i \equiv 1 \pmod {11}$

hence:

$98^n-1 \equiv 9 \pmod {11}$

7. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Thank you very much.

8. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
But still, how do you know that $98^{n} -1 \equiv 9 (\mod 11)$ when $n$ is odd?
Also:

$98 \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$

So the entire proof can be written as a one-liner:

$98^{76543}+21 \equiv (-1)^{76543}+10 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}$

9. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by undefined
Also:

$98 \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$

So the entire proof can be written as a one-liner:

$98^{76543}+21 \equiv (-1)^{76543}+10 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}$
Thanks, this is brilliant. Did you observer that $98 \equiv -1 (\mod 11)$ and then work on this congruence like
$98 \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} \equiv (-1)^{76543} \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv -1 + 21 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 20 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}$?

10. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
Thanks, this is brilliant. Did you observer that $98 \equiv -1 (\mod 11)$ and then work on this congruence like
$98 \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} \equiv (-1)^{76543} \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv -1 + 21 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 20 \pmod{11}$
$98^{76543} + 21 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}$?
Well, I didn't do it in exactly that order, but that's equivalent. The steps can be written for example like this:

$98^{76543} \equiv (-1)^{76543} \equiv -1 \pmod{11}$

$21 \equiv 10 \pmod{11}$

$98^{76543}+21 \equiv -1 + 10 \equiv 9 \pmod{11}$

But anyone reasonably familiar with congruences should be able to follow the one-liner I wrote above without any intermediate steps.

In general, in the context of an exam, you may be presented with $a^b \pmod{n}$ such that gcd(a,n)=1 and be expected to recognise that Euler's theorem applies. But if $a$ is congruent to 1, 0, or -1 (mod n), then you should definitely take advantage of that to make calculations very easy. And there are other related topics you can learn about if you are interested in such things.

11. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Thanks for the advice. We haven't done Totient functions or Euler's theorem yet. What related topics are you referring to? Are they shortcuts for solving congruence problems or more advanced topics?

12. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Originally Posted by math2011
Thanks for the advice. We haven't done Totient functions or Euler's theorem yet. What related topics are you referring to? Are they shortcuts for solving congruence problems or more advanced topics?
A little of both, I guess. The Chinese Remainder Theorem can be used if gcd(a,n)>1, and (mainly discussed in a computer science context) there's an algorithm for fast modular exponentiation by repeated squaring. Using such concepts you could compute things like the common residue of $a^{b^{c^d}} \pmod{n}$ for nontrivial a,b,c,d,n. (And the numbers can get very large very quickly; for example, $2^{2^{3^3}}$ has 40403563 digits.) You probably won't get something like that on a test, but nevertheless it's possible that having extra knowledge might provide a shortcut for certain problems.

13. ## Re: Show that 98^76543 + 21 is not divisible by 11.

Thanks a lot for your explainations!