How do you divide 17 apples and put them in three boxes?

Such that:

Box1 get 1/2 total number of apples.

Box2 get 1/3 total number of apples.

Box3 gets 1/9 total number of apples.

Hint: Do not cut apple in half.

Printable View

- Jul 28th 2010, 05:45 AMracewithferrariSimple Math puzzle of dividing...
How do you divide 17 apples and put them in three boxes?

**Such that:**

Box1 get 1/2 total number of apples.

Box2 get 1/3 total number of apples.

Box3 gets 1/9 total number of apples.

Hint: Do not cut apple in half. - Jul 28th 2010, 05:54 AMArchie Meade
I suppose you could make a hole in two of the boxes.

Put the two boxes together at the hole and put one apple in the hole.

You could say half the apple is in one box and half in the other,

so that the fractions don't work out,

or you could say (since you can take the in-between apple is in 2 boxes)

one box contains 9 instead of 8.5, another contains 6 and the last contains 2.

Alternatively, I can loan you an apple.

Then you can put 9 in one box, 6 in another and 2 in the third.

You can put the apple I loaned you in your pocket. - Jul 28th 2010, 06:02 AMracewithferrari
Your second answer is correct.