# Problem 50

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page
Page 1 of 2 12 Last
• Nov 12th 2008, 03:56 AM
CaptainBlack
Problem 50
An easy one:

Let $\displaystyle x_i=2^i,\ i=1,.., 16$

Find the minimum of the function:

$\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{16} |x-x_i|$

(I had thought I had already posted this, did it disapear for a reason or am I just misremembering events (Cool))

CB
• Nov 21st 2008, 02:40 AM
CaptainBlack
Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainBlack
An easy one:

Let $\displaystyle x_i=2^i,\ i=1,.., 16$

Find the minimum of the function:

$\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{16} |x-x_i|$

(I had thought I had already posted this, did it disapear for a reason or am I just misremembering events (Cool))

CB

OK a clue.

Given the function:

$\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{2} |x-x_i|$

where $\displaystyle x_2>x_1$ what is the minimum of $\displaystyle f(x)$ and where is it achieved.

CB
• Nov 21st 2008, 11:04 PM
David24
Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainBlack
An easy one:

Let $\displaystyle x_i=2^i,\ i=1,.., 16$

Find the minimum of the function:

$\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{16} |x-x_i|$

(I had thought I had already posted this, did it disapear for a reason or am I just misremembering events (Cool))

CB

hey mate,

without going into two much detail, I believe the solution lies between the intersection of |x - 2| = |x - 2^16| which over the region of intersection becomes
x - 2 = 2^16 - x
x = 2^15 + 1

am I completely off the mark? if not please let me know and I will post my full solution,

Cheers,

David
• Nov 21st 2008, 11:43 PM
CaptainBlack
Quote:

Originally Posted by David24
hey mate,

without going into two much detail, I believe the solution lies between the intersection of |x - 2| = |x - 2^16| which over the region of intersection becomes
x - 2 = 2^16 - x
x = 2^15 + 1

am I completely off the mark? if not please let me know and I will post my full solution,

Cheers,

David

Try writing in English, that is gobbledy gook.

CB
• Nov 22nd 2008, 12:09 AM
David24
Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainBlack
Try writing in English, that is gobbledy gook.

CB

CaptainBlack,

Am I correct in conjecturing that the value of x which minimises f(x) satisfies,

|x-2| =|x-2^16| ?

David

ps - I apologise for any grammatical and or spelling mistakes that may be present in the above statement.
• Nov 22nd 2008, 12:22 AM
NonCommAlg
this problem is for the moderators only! lol (just kidding!)

suppose $\displaystyle a_1 \leq a_2 \leq \cdots \leq a_n,$ and $\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^n |x-a_i|.$ put: $\displaystyle m=\left \lfloor \frac{n}{2} \right \rfloor.$ prove that: $\displaystyle \min f(x)=\sum_{k=1}^m (a_{n+1-k} - a_k).$
• Nov 22nd 2008, 01:44 AM
CaptainBlack
Quote:

Originally Posted by David24
CaptainBlack,

Am I correct in conjecturing that the value of x which minimises f(x) satisfies,

|x-2| =|x-2^16| ?

David

ps - I apologise for any grammatical and or spelling mistakes that may be present in the above statement.

Well lets see,

$\displaystyle |x-2|=|x-2^{16}|$

implies (assuming $\displaystyle 2 \le x \le 2^{16}$ anyway) that:

$\displaystyle x-2=2^{16}-x$

or:

$\displaystyle x=2^8-1$

Now lets do some calculations:

Code:

>i=1:16; > >x=[2^8-1:2^8+1]'           255           256           257 > >s=abs(x-2^i); >S=sum(s)       130052       130050       130050 >
So we conclude that, no your proposed condition does not define the solution.

CB
• Nov 22nd 2008, 02:46 AM
David24
Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainBlack
Well lets see,

$\displaystyle |x-2|=|x-2^{16}|$

implies (assuming $\displaystyle 2 \le x \le 2^{16}$ anyway) that:

$\displaystyle x-2=2^{16}-x$

or:

$\displaystyle x=2^8-1$

Now lets do some calculations:

Code:

>i=1:16; > >x=[2^8-1:2^8+1]'           255           256           257 > >s=abs(x-2^i); >S=sum(s)       130052       130050       130050 >
So we conclude that, no your proposed condition does not define the solution.

CB

CaptainBlack,

Thanks for your response, I will have to keep working on it.
• Nov 23rd 2008, 11:26 AM
running-gag
Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainBlack
An easy one:

Let $\displaystyle x_i=2^i,\ i=1,.., 16$

Find the minimum of the function:

$\displaystyle f(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{16} |x-x_i|$

(I had thought I had already posted this, did it disapear for a reason or am I just misremembering events (Cool))

CB

Hi,
By deriving f on each interval $\displaystyle [2^j,2^{j+1}]$ we find
$\displaystyle \frac{df}{dx}=2j-16$
Therefore f is decreasing up to $\displaystyle 2^8$ (up to j=7) is constant between $\displaystyle 2^8$ and $\displaystyle 2^9$ (for j=8) and increasing from $\displaystyle 2^9$ (from j=9)
The minimum of f is reached between $\displaystyle 2^8$ and $\displaystyle 2^9$
• Nov 23rd 2008, 01:47 PM
CaptainBlack
Quote:

Originally Posted by running-gag
Hi,
By deriving f on each interval $\displaystyle [2^j,2^{j+1}]$ we find
$\displaystyle \frac{df}{dx}=2j-16$
Therefore f is decreasing up to $\displaystyle 2^8$ (up to j=7) is constant between $\displaystyle 2^8$ and $\displaystyle 2^9$ (for j=8) and increasing from $\displaystyle 2^9$ (from j=9)
The minimum of f is reached between $\displaystyle 2^8$ and $\displaystyle 2^9$

It can be done more neatly without calculus.

CB
• Dec 1st 2008, 09:50 AM
lcmarincek
|x-2^i|, where i is a constant, is a continuous function. So, the sum of |x-2^i|, i = 1 to 16, is a continuous function, too.
As a continuous function, its minimum/maximum is at at its derivative is 0, or where its derivative has a discontinuity from prositive to negative or vice-versa.

If x-2^i >= 0 (this means x >= 2^i), then |x-2^i| = x-2^i

If x-2^i < 0 (this means x < 2^i), then |x-2^i| = 2^i-x.

We can divide the x values in 18 parts.

Part 1: x <2^1:
f(x) = sum of (2^i-x), i = 1 to 16 = something - 16*x .This is a line with derivative -16.

part 2: 2^1 <= x < 2^2:
f(x) = x-2^1 + sum of (2^1-x), i = 2 to 16 = something - 14*x. This is a line with derivative -14.

and so on, till part 9: 2^8 <= x < 2^9:
f(x) = (sum of (x-2^i), i = 1 to 8) + (sum of (2^i-x), i = 9 to 16) = something (no dependence on x). This is a line with derivative 0.

part 10: 2^9 <= x < 2^10:
f(x) = (sum of (x-2^i), i = 1 to 9) + (sim of (2^i-x), i = 10 to 16) = something + 2*x. This is a line with derivative 2.

From part 10 on, the line segments have positive derivative. This means that the minimum of the function is at part 9, and its value at this part is:
(sum of 2^i, i = 9 to 16) - (sum of 2^i, i = 1 to 8) = 130560 - 510 = 130050
• Dec 5th 2008, 12:22 AM
CaptainBlack
Quote:

Originally Posted by lcmarincek
|x-2^i|, where i is a constant, is a continuous function. So, the sum of |x-2^i|, i = 1 to 16, is a continuous function, too.
As a continuous function, its minimum/maximum is at at its derivative is 0, or where its derivative has a discontinuity from prositive to negative or vice-versa.

If x-2^i >= 0 (this means x >= 2^i), then |x-2^i| = x-2^i

If x-2^i < 0 (this means x < 2^i), then |x-2^i| = 2^i-x.

We can divide the x values in 18 parts.

Part 1: x <2^1:
f(x) = sum of (2^i-x), i = 1 to 16 = something - 16*x .This is a line with derivative -16.

part 2: 2^1 <= x < 2^2:
f(x) = x-2^1 + sum of (2^1-x), i = 2 to 16 = something - 14*x. This is a line with derivative -14.

and so on, till part 9: 2^8 <= x < 2^9:
f(x) = (sum of (x-2^i), i = 1 to 8) + (sum of (2^i-x), i = 9 to 16) = something (no dependence on x). This is a line with derivative 0.

part 10: 2^9 <= x < 2^10:
f(x) = (sum of (x-2^i), i = 1 to 9) + (sim of (2^i-x), i = 10 to 16) = something + 2*x. This is a line with derivative 2.

From part 10 on, the line segments have positive derivative. This means that the minimum of the function is at part 9, and its value at this part is:
(sum of 2^i, i = 9 to 16) - (sum of 2^i, i = 1 to 8) = 130560 - 510 = 130050

As I said previously, this can be done more easily and elegantly without calculus. Also a hint on how to do this has already been posted.

CB
• Dec 5th 2008, 09:09 AM
cl85
Here's my attempt:
f(x) measures the distance of x to 16 points, namely 2, 4, 8, 16, ... , 2^16.

Suppose we let x to be less than 2. Then we can decrease f(x) by increasing x towards 2 since this decreases the distance of x to all 16 points.

So what happens when we increase x pass 2? We're getting further away from a single point, ie 2, but at the same time, we are decreasing our distance to 15 points. The net effect is a decrease in f(x).

The key observation here is that if we change x by a fix amount, the change in the distance is the same for all points(some are positive change, while others are negative, but the absolute value is the same).

This implies that we should keep increasing x to decrease f(x) as long as we are decreasing the distance to more points than the number of points that we are getting further away.

Following this logic, we arrive at the answer that f(x) is minimum between the region 2^8 and 2^9, which has 8 points less than it and 8 points more.
• Jan 1st 2009, 06:30 PM
fobos3
Okay. The derivative of |x-a| is:
1 if x-a>0
0 if x=0
-1 if x-a<0

Since we have a sum we the derivative of f(x) is the sum of the derivatives of the modulus:f'(x)=$\displaystyle \sum _{i=1}^{16} \left(\left|x-x_i\right|\right)'$

If f'(x) is to be 0 we can't have some of the elements $\displaystyle |x-x_i|$ to be zero because then all the other elements can't be zero. We will have 15 elements that can be 1 or -1 and one which is 0 and their sum cannot be 0.

Suppose we have a number i=n such as for i>n $\displaystyle x-x_i<0$. This is easy enough to prove $\displaystyle x-x_i>x-x_{i+1}$. We will also have $\displaystyle x-x_i>0$ for i<=n since there can't be a zero term. From f'(x)=0 we can conclude that n=8 (8 times 1 and 8 times -1=0).

So $\displaystyle x-x_9<0$ for n>8
$\displaystyle x<2^9$
and
$\displaystyle x-x_8>0$ for n<=8
$\displaystyle x>2^8$

All that is left is to prove that this is a minimum but I'll leave that to you.

Don't know if someone has suggested this. I didn't read all the posts.
• Mar 12th 2009, 02:03 AM
chisigma
In order to have an idea about how we can solve the problem let’s consider the minimum of this function…

$\displaystyle f(x)= \sum_ {i=1}^{2} |x-2^{i}|$ (1)

… which is represented [in blue] here…

The (1) is in fact a ‘straight-line function’ the slope of which changes in $\displaystyle x=2$ and $\displaystyle x=4$. More exactly, the function starts with negative slope $\displaystyle s=-2$, in $\displaystyle x=2$ becames ‘flat’ [$\displaystyle s=0$, and for $\displaystyle x > 4$ the slope is positive [$\displaystyle s=2$]. The ‘minimum’ of (1) in fact is not rescticted to a single point, but in extended to the interval $\displaystyle 2 \le x \le 4$, where is $\displaystyle f(x)=2$. In similar way we can ‘attach’ the proposed problem, i.e. finding the minimum of…

$\displaystyle f(x)= \sum_ {i=1}^{16} |x-2^{i}|$ (2)

As the (1), the (2) is also ‘straight-line’ . In $\displaystyle x=0$ is…

$\displaystyle f(0)= \sum_ {i=1}^{16} 2^{i}$$\displaystyle = 2 \cdot (2^{16}-1)=131070$

The functions starts with negative slope $\displaystyle s=-16$ and each time that $\displaystyle x=2^{i}$ the slope is increased by $\displaystyle +2$. So we have…

$\displaystyle x=0, s=-16; x=2, s=-14; x=4, s=-12;\dots; x=2^{7}, s=-2; x=2^{8}, s=0;\dots$

So the functions become ‘flat’ in the interval $\displaystyle 256 \le x \le 512$ and here exhibits its ‘minimum’ which is [if no mistakes of mine…] …

$\displaystyle f(2^{8})= \sum_{i=1}^{16} |2^{8}-2^{i}|= 2\cdot (2^{8}-1)^ {2}= 130050$

Regards
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page
Page 1 of 2 12 Last