Let, where
, and
.
Prove that
if and only if
.
Printable View
Let, where
, and
.
Prove that
if and only if
.
I want to give the proof for those who were interested.
First of all, a very indirect proof of this result can be found in [1, Lemma 2].
References
[1] B.G. Zhang and J.S. Yu, Existence of positive solutions for neutral differential equations,
Science in China Series A 35 (1992), no. 11, 1306--1313. View PDF
I will here give a shorter proof for a more generalized form.
Lemma 1. Letbe an increasing divergent sequence and
.
Then
if and only if
provided that
.____________________________(*)
Proof. We shall consider two different cases.
- Let
.
In this case, the claim is true since both the integral and the sum diverge.- Let
.
If we define
for
,
thenis decreasing on
.
We compute that
where we have changed the order of integration in the last step.
Then an equivalent claim reads as follows.
if and only if
.
Defineby
for
.
Adopting the convention that the empty sum is, we get
for all
,
which proves that
and
diverge or converge together since by the assumption (*), we learn that
and
diverge or converge together.
This completes the proof.________________________________
Corollary 1. If in addition to the assumptions of Lemma 1, we have
.___________________________(**)
Then
if and only if
.
Remark. In Corollary 1, if we letand
for
, we get
the result in the first post. Trivially, in this case (*) and (**) hold.