The graph of the even function y=f(x) consists of 4 line segments, as shown above. Which of the following statements about f is false?

(A)

(B)

(C)

(D)

(E) does not exist.

Printable View

- December 31st 2008, 09:27 PMxxlvhLimits Problem

The graph of the even function y=f(x) consists of 4 line segments, as shown above. Which of the following statements about f is false?

(A)

(B)

(C)

(D)

(E) does not exist.

- January 1st 2009, 12:18 AMkalagota
- January 1st 2009, 09:38 PMxxlvh
Hmm I think I had eliminated answers D, and E. The slope of the tangent line at 2 equals 1, and at x = 3 where f(x) has a corner I don't think the graph is differentiable.

A and C I'm completely puzzled on...I hadn't made any real attempt to figure out what they mean.

B was my original guess for this question, because f(x) is not differentiable at x = 0. - January 1st 2009, 09:49 PMRapha
- January 1st 2009, 10:18 PMAryth
This question confuses me because the graph is not differentiable at -3, 0, and 3. And these points are not differentiable solely because the left and right limits differ, it's similar to the problem with differentiating at x = 0. If this is indeed the case, then A through C do not exist, D results in an indeterminate form, but can be reduced using L'Hopital's rule, but even so the limit is still 0, which makes D false as well. E is the only true statement. Since f is not differentiable at x = 3, then there is no true limit at 3, which means that it does not exist in any context with reference to f. So E is true and the rest are false.

- January 1st 2009, 10:41 PMkalagota
i say that the only false here is (B).

(A) is true.. first, and thus

(C) is true.. take note that on the interval the function can be defined as and hence on this interval. thus, the numerator is always . and therefore the limit as approaches is .

(D) is true.. you can check that this is true by taking some values..

(E) is true.. i you check the left- and right- hand limit, they go on different values. and thus the limit does not exist.

(B) is false.. you can do similar thing like (E) and you will see that the limit should not exist.

----------------------------------

i just avoided the concept of derivatives here. but in case you already know it, (B), (D) and (E) are definitions of derivatives at the points 0, 2 and 3 respectively.. - January 2nd 2009, 07:14 AMAryth
How is D true?

When you split it all up, you get:

It's easy to see that the limit as x approaches 2 is 2, and that the function value at 2 is also 2. The limit of x as it approaches 2 is also 2, and the limit of a constant is the constant itself:

This is an indeterminate form, so we can do L'Hopital's rule (xxlvh, you may or may not be familiar with this):

The derivative of f'(x) at x = 2 is 1, so:

By the way, it is a definition of the derivative, but only when you need to find a c for the mean value theorem (Because Rolle's theorem usually assumes that f(a) = f(b) it is always a numerator of 0). - January 2nd 2009, 07:43 AMJester
- January 2nd 2009, 08:39 AMSoroban
Hello, xxlvh!

Quote:

The graph of the even function y=f(x) consists of 4 line segments,

as shown above. .Which of the following statements about f is false?

. .

If we can interpret them, we can virtually "eyeball" the problem.

is the height of the function at

The statement becomes: .

It says: the height of a point, as the point approaches the origin, is zero.

(A) is true.

Since is an__even__function,

Hence, the numerator is always 0.

(C) is true.

This says: the slope of at is 1.

Looking at the graph, (D) is true.

This says: the slope at does not exist.

Looking at the graph, (E) is true.

Therefore, (B) is false . . . why?

We have: .

This says: the slope at is 0.

And we can see that this slope does not exist.