Thread: Volume from revolved area?

Hi,

Hope I can explain this well. I have a function that gives me the deflection of a circular/disk membrane as a function of the radius. From this I can get the cross sectional area/profile of the disks displacement in terms of the radius. I would now like to revolve this area to create a volume.

My problem is that when ever I look this up on the internet I find equations for the volume if I revolve the area aournd the x-axis whilst I want to revolve it around the y-axis.

My inital attempt was to invert the function tbut this has proven impossible

My questions are:

1) Would the volume be same reguardless of which axis I choose to revolve around?

2) Is there an better way of doing this?

Originally Posted by Bwts

Hi,

Hope I can explain this well. I have a function that gives me the deflection of a circular/disk membrane as a function of the radius. From this I can get the cross sectional area/profile of the disks displacement in terms of the radius. I would now like to revolve this area to create a volume.

My problem is that when ever I look this up on the internet I find equations for the volume if I revolve the area aournd the x-axis whilst I want to revolve it around the y-axis.

My inital attempt was to invert the function tbut this has proven impossible

My questions are:

1) Would the volume be same reguardless of which axis I choose to revolve around?

2) Is there an better way of doing this?

If you want to revolve the region around the y axis, first write the function as a function of y, i.e. x = f(y).

Then, imagine the area being approximated using horizontal rectangular strips.

Each rectangular strip has length and width , (some small change in y).

When you rotate the strips, they create cylinders, each of radius and depth .

So the volume of each strip is , and therefore the volume of the region is approximated by



As you increase the number of subdivisions, i.e. make and , this sum converges to an integral, and the approximation becomes exact.

So , where are your y endpoints.

Hi,

Thanks for your speedy response. My problem is getting x=f(y) see attched image.

evrything is constant except x. I keep getting a nasty looking polynomial in x which I cant reduce further

Originally Posted by Bwts

1) Would the volume be same reguardless of which axis I choose to revolve around?

No. Try to imagine the two.

Originally Posted by Bwts

2) Is there a better way of doing this?

Yes, integrate along the x axis and rotate the vertical strips around the y axis to make hollow cylinders.

The formula is then



... as explained admirably at Solid of revolution - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. I thought that page had a typo, but I was misreading 'revolving an area between curve and x-axis' as 'revolving around the x axis'. Maybe you did, too...

Originally Posted by Bwts

My problem is that when ever I look this up on the internet I find equations for the volume if I revolve the area aournd the x-axis

Hi Tom,

Just so I'm clear. I should intergrate my function along x then multiply this intergrated function by the original function and intergrate the product between my x limits?

Integrate with respect to x, yes, and between your x limits, yes... not sure I follow your multiplying proposal... what you should be planning, anyway, is to integrate the product which is the result of multiplying your function (the height of each hollow cyclinder) by 2 pi x (the circumference of the same cylinder).

Ahh yes I get you now...thanks Tom