
New Binary operation
Hey
Im new here, and i'm not sure where to put this Q,
I was studying for the AMO, and I came across a problem in the 2004 AIMO which has me completely stuck (Headbang)...
A new binary operation ? defined on all positive x and y, satisfies the following conditions:
i x?x = x+2
ii x?y = y?x
iii x?(x+y) = x+y
x?yy
Given the above, find 11?8
please explain how to do this, i have been to other forums, and unless I ask, they just give a number.
Thanks

Hi
From ii
11 ? 8 = 8 ? 11
From iii
8 ? 11 = 8 ? (8 + 3) = (8 ? 3) 11 / 3
Now we need to find 8 ? 3
From ii
8 ? 3 = 3 ? 8
From iii
3 ? 8 = 3 ? (3 + 5) = (3 ? 5) 8 / 5
Now we need to find 8 ? 3
From iii
3 ? 5 = 3 ? (3 + 2) = (3 ? 2) 5 / 2
Now we need to find 3 ? 2
From ii
3 ? 2 = 2 ? 3
2 ? 3 = 2 ? (2 + 1) = (2 ? 1) 3 / 1
Now we need to find 2 ? 1
From ii
2 ? 1 = 1 ? 2
1 ? 2 = 1 ? (1 + 1) = (1 ? 1) 2 / 1
From i
1 ? 1 = 1 + 2 = 3
Therefore you can go up the chain to get 11 ? 8

Thanks runninggag
just one Q, where did you get (8?3)11/3 ???
then, (3?5)8/5 etc
all the way down?
thanks

Rule iii is
If you substitute x = 8 and y = 3 you get
Therefore

yep, thanks, i see,
just i was keeping x=8, y=11 from the 8?11=8?(8+3), so i got (8?11)11/3
thanks