" If the occurrence of B makes A more likely, does the occurrence of A make B more likely?

I guess yes. But I could not figure out the reason. Thanks~~(Wondering)

Printable View

- Jun 2nd 2008, 04:29 AMshiningstarpxxA problem come from "Introduction to Probability Models"
" If the occurrence of B makes A more likely, does the occurrence of A make B more likely?

I guess yes. But I could not figure out the reason. Thanks~~(Wondering) - Jun 2nd 2008, 05:13 AMSoroban
Hello, shiningstarpxx!

An interesting question . . .

Quote:

If the occurrence of $\displaystyle B$ makes $\displaystyle A$ more likely,

does the occurrence of $\displaystyle A$ make $\displaystyle B$ more likely?

We need Bayes' Theorem: .$\displaystyle P(X\,|\,Y) \;=\;\frac{P(X \wedge\,Y)}{P(Y)}$

We are told that, if $\displaystyle B$ happens, $\displaystyle A$ is more likely to happen.

. . That is, the probability of $\displaystyle A$, given $\displaystyle B$, is greater than the probability of $\displaystyle A$.

In symbols: .$\displaystyle P(A\,|\,B) \:> \:P(A)$

This means: .$\displaystyle \frac{P(A \wedge B)}{P(B)} \:> \:P(A) \quad\Rightarrow\quad P(A\wedge B) \:>\:P(A)\!\cdot\!P(B)$

Hence, we have: .$\displaystyle \frac{P(B \wedge A)}{P(A)} \:>\:P(B) \quad\Rightarrow\quad P(B\,|\,A) \:>\:P(B)$

Therefore, the probability of $\displaystyle B$, given $\displaystyle A$, is greater than the probability of $\displaystyle B.$

. . The occurence of $\displaystyle A$ makes $\displaystyle B$ more likely.

- Jun 2nd 2008, 05:14 AMmr fantastic
What you're asking is the following:

Does Pr(A | B) > Pr(A) => Pr(B | A) > Pr(B) ?

The answer is yes. Consider:

$\displaystyle \Pr(A | B) \, \Pr(B) = \Pr(B | A) \, \Pr(A) \Rightarrow \frac{\Pr(A | B)}{\Pr(A)} = \frac{\Pr(B | A)}{\Pr(B)}$.

But it's given that $\displaystyle \Pr(A | B) > \Pr(A) \Rightarrow \frac{\Pr(A | B)}{\Pr(A)} > 1$.

Therefore $\displaystyle \frac{\Pr(B | A)}{\Pr(B)} > 1$ and the implication follows.

**Edit:**Too fast for me*this*time, Soroban. But I like to think our replies ......*complement*each other lol!