Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 23 of 23

Math Help - How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

  1. #16
    Super Member
    Joined
    Oct 2012
    From
    Ireland
    Posts
    597
    Thanks
    165

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Quote Originally Posted by laban1 View Post
    I prefere to look at it as
    n is always the number of timeslots - one sample per timeslot
    Sometimes I dont get to sample every minute in some areas.
    In fact, the timeslots are directly given by the sample-rate.
    If i get 6 samples per hour my timeslots are 10min per definition. If i get 60 samples per hour my timeslots are 1min.
    Ok then I suggest you use 10 min time intervals to avoid getting lots of zeros. If you have 6 timeslots per hour then you can measure for 10 hours to get 60 samples. Of course the more samples you can get the better


    That was bad news I think! If I find the constant, then I could subtract it and then do the Pearson X^2 ?
    On a Poisson, What is over-dispersion really comming from
    , finding more high values weighting the tail than for the polulation? I feel it would be the opposite. or is it due to noise that squared get higher weight since that is usually not Zero centered ?
    If you found the constant then you could subtract it from every measurement and make a confidence interval for the mean. Since you can change your time intervals to 1 minute it should be very easy to find the constant if you are only monitoring 10 houses.
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  2. #17
    Super Member
    Joined
    Oct 2012
    From
    Ireland
    Posts
    597
    Thanks
    165

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    On a Poisson, What is over-dispersion really coming from, finding more high values weighting the tail than for the population? I feel it would be the opposite. or is it due to noise that squared get higher weight since that is usually not Zero centered ?
    Yes the over-dispersion comes from observing the higher values more often than you would expect if the system was a poisson distribution exactly.
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  3. #18
    Junior Member
    Joined
    Sep 2013
    From
    Sweden
    Posts
    27
    Thanks
    1

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Hi again and thanks for your input!

    a)Any thoughts about my reasoning about ci mean / ci variance?

    b)"Yes the over-dispersion comes from observing the higher values more often than you would expect if the system was a poisson distribution exactly."
    What I was hoping for was if you had some sort of physical explaination on why this "often" is the case.

    c)I'm thinking of two ways on using/looking at the data.
    First, is taking each night in a month and make an estimation of the mean for each night. And then making some "mean of mean"
    Or
    Gathering all month in one "gigantic" experiment.
    Any thoughts on which one would be preferable?

    d) Do you have any experience/ thoughts on using Pearson's?
    3) How would I use this Pearson? If Pearson would e.g. be 1,2 then I should divide my estimation of the mean by variance by 1,2 to get a "truer" value of the mean?

    4) Lets say I have 60 timeslots each night and I have 30 nights in a month. Should I do this Pearson value for each night, somewhat different every night, correct each estimate of mean by variance, with pearson, that would be 30 pearson calculations over a month period?

    Regards!
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  4. #19
    Super Member
    Joined
    Oct 2012
    From
    Ireland
    Posts
    597
    Thanks
    165

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Quote Originally Posted by laban1 View Post
    Hi again and thanks for your input!

    a)Any thoughts about my reasoning about ci mean / ci variance?
    I'm not sure which part of your reasoning you are referring to.

    b) What I was hoping for was if you had some sort of physical explaination on why this "often" is the case.
    I think it is just because unknown factors make observing those rare values in the tail of the Poisson distribution more common. It is not the first time I have heard that tail values are often more frequent than expected but I'm not sure why unknown factors tend to make tail values more likely instead of less likely. Maybe it is because when unknown factors increase the tail values a little bit it is more noticable than when unknown factors increase the common results a little bit. (example of an unknown factor for your study could be when it is half-time of a football game then many people in the 10 houses might get up and use the toilet).

    c)I'm thinking of two ways on using/looking at the data.
    First, is taking each night in a month and make an estimation of the mean for each night. And then making some "mean of mean"
    Or
    Gathering all month in one "gigantic" experiment.
    Any thoughts on which one would be preferable?
    One gigantic experiment would be better than getting the average of 30 variances or means.

    d) Do you have any experience/ thoughts on using Pearson's?
    3) How would I use this Pearson? If Pearson would e.g. be 1,2 then I should divide my estimation of the mean by variance by 1,2 to get a "truer" value of the mean?
    once you get \phi=\frac{\chi^2}{n-p} then you should divide your estimation of the variance by \phi to get an estimation of the mean.

    4) Lets say I have 60 timeslots each night and I have 30 nights in a month. Should I do this Pearson value for each night, somewhat different every night, correct each estimate of mean by variance, with pearson, that would be 30 pearson calculations over a month period?
    You should do one calculation of the Pearson value after 30 nights
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  5. #20
    Junior Member
    Joined
    Sep 2013
    From
    Sweden
    Posts
    27
    Thanks
    1

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Hi again!

    a) Any thoughts about my reasoning about ci mean / ci variance?
    I'm not sure which part of your reasoning you are referring to.

    Why would that be proof saying anything about the c.i. of variance? (the ci of mean) If you think about it, mean and median are very closely related, indeed if the population is not "screwed" the result is interchangeable. But, the variance is taken from the numbers squared, so the generalisation i feel would be very bold. If the solution is that easy why are they not telling that in the article. Simply "the c.i. of variance is always the same as c.i for mean in a poisson" Could you help me find a believable article saying that?

    One "proof" that saying that could be wrong
    If we just for one moment compere to ci of Norm-distr. Then I guess you know that the c.i of mean is T-distr, that is, symetrical Norm-alike and becoming more or less a Norm if the no samples is 30 or more. Now, if we look at the c.i. of variance it is as you know X^2 and not symetrical at all ! But can be said to be Norm-alike and becoming more or less a Norm if the no samples is 50 or more. (Compare the numbers 30 and 50, I believe this is an indication on ci of Var being greater.)

    Now in a the poisson; If λ=np is greater than about 10, then the normal distribution is a good approximation. So for np>10 the ci for mean and variance are not the same.Futhermore let np=8 to show some true "Poissonic" behaivoir then the ci of the X^2 would not hold true, but the basic shape of the X^2 would be intact.

    -----------------------------------
    You should do one calculation of the Pearson value after 30 nights

    One thing, when I'm setting up my model to compere
    with my measured data, how do I know my model is right?
    Since I'm gathering data to get the model, how do I look at this?

    I just need Lambda =n*p, right but if I don't?



    Thanks again, for your feedback on Pearson!
    Last edited by laban1; October 1st 2013 at 10:35 AM.
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  6. #21
    Super Member
    Joined
    Oct 2012
    From
    Ireland
    Posts
    597
    Thanks
    165

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Quote Originally Posted by laban1 View Post
    One "proof" that saying that could be wrong
    If we just for one moment compere to ci of Norm-distr. Then I guess you know that the c.i of mean is T-distr, that is, symetrical Norm-alike and becoming more or less a Norm if the no samples is 30 or more. Now, if we look at the c.i. of variance it is as you know X^2 and not symetrical at all ! But can be said to be Norm-alike and becoming more or less a Norm if the no samples is 50 or more. (Compare the numbers 30 and 50, I believe this is an indication on ci of Var being greater.)

    Now in a the poisson; If λ=np is greater than about 10, then the normal distribution is a good approximation. So for np>10 the ci for mean and variance are not the same.Futhermore let np=8 to show some true "Poissonic" behaivoir then the ci of the X^2 would not hold true, but the basic shape of the X^2 would be intact.
    I said before that the confidence interval of the mean would not be the same size as the c.i. of the variance. In my example the c.i. of the mean was smaller than the c.i. of the median. I can not find a proof about the confidence interval of the variance also being a confidence interval of the mean but the people at stack exchange agree with me that it is a confidence interval for the value \lambda whether that is the mean or the variance Stack exchange
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  7. #22
    Junior Member
    Joined
    Sep 2013
    From
    Sweden
    Posts
    27
    Thanks
    1

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Hi!
    Could you comment were my reasoning above is faulty in your oppinion?

    From Sack exchange (your link futher down)
    "Your approach is basically correct but heavily depends on the strong distributional assumption you are making. If it is violated, even for very large samples, the confidence regions wont have the stated coverage probabilities. That's why statisticians try to avoid such reasoning if there are more robust methods available "

    It's part of my reasoning:
    The mean is always a mean no matter of distribution. That you estimating mean from variance means at least two drawbacks.
    1. You are making a strong distributional assumption, Is your reality a true mathematical poisson?
    2. Do have sufficiant and reliable data (over dispersion suggest not)
    3. The squared propery of the variance makes measurements more sensitive to outliers.

    For me it's quite obvious, I'd like to here why you think this is wrong.

    Thanks for your interest!
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

  8. #23
    Super Member
    Joined
    Oct 2012
    From
    Ireland
    Posts
    597
    Thanks
    165

    Re: How to estimate Variance of a Poisson distribution?

    Quote Originally Posted by laban1 View Post
    The mean is always a mean no matter of distribution. That you estimating mean from variance means at least two drawbacks.
    1. You are making a strong distributional assumption, Is your reality a true mathematical poisson?
    2. Do have sufficiant and reliable data (over dispersion suggest not)
    3. The squared propery of the variance makes measurements more sensitive to outliers.
    1. Yes I did make that assumption, its up to you if you want to make it too. Sometimes you have to make assumptions in order to simplify things enough to be able to calculate it.
    2. I don't know, is your data reliable? If the system is a perfect poisson distribution then it should be.
    3. It is more sensitive so the confidence interval would be bigger to account for that. The chance that the variance lies outside a 95% confidence interval is still 5%.
    Last edited by Shakarri; October 5th 2013 at 01:55 AM.
    Follow Math Help Forum on Facebook and Google+

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Similar Math Help Forum Discussions

  1. Poisson Distribution - Expressing Variance that is free of Mu.
    Posted in the Advanced Statistics Forum
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: November 10th 2009, 11:51 AM
  2. [SOLVED] Variance of the poisson distribution
    Posted in the Advanced Statistics Forum
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: February 24th 2009, 09:20 AM
  3. MSE of Normal Variance Estimate
    Posted in the Advanced Statistics Forum
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: January 28th 2009, 10:17 PM
  4. Poisson distribution mean and variance
    Posted in the Advanced Statistics Forum
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: October 27th 2008, 04:00 AM
  5. Probability for estimate/poisson distribution
    Posted in the Advanced Statistics Forum
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: May 6th 2008, 07:51 PM

Search Tags


/mathhelpforum @mathhelpforum