Arbitrary intersection of the open set (-1/n,1/n) where n is a natural number is zero.

Also the arbitrary intersection of the set (-r,r) where r is a positive real numbers is zero.

Could someone please explain, why is it like this ?

Printable View

- September 22nd 2013, 07:42 AMmrmaaza123Arbitrary intersection of open sets
Arbitrary intersection of the open set (-1/n,1/n) where n is a natural number is zero.

Also the arbitrary intersection of the set (-r,r) where r is a positive real numbers is zero.

Could someone please explain, why is it like this ? - September 22nd 2013, 09:51 AMPlatoRe: Arbitrary intersection of open sets
- September 22nd 2013, 01:41 PMHallsofIvyRe: Arbitrary intersection of open sets
Suppose x is a positive number. Then 1/x is positive number and so there exist a positive integer, N, such that N> 1/x. But then x> 1/N and so x is NOT in (-1/N, 1/N) for

**that**N so is not in the intersection.

Suppose x is a negative number. Then -1/x is a positive number and the above applies. But if there is N such that N> -1/x, then x< -1/N and so x is NOT in (-1/N, 1/N).

(The statement, as given, is not true- the intersection is NOT "zero", it is the set whose only member is 0.)

Quote:

Also the arbitrary intersection of the set (-r,r) where r is a positive real numbers is zero.

(Again, the intersection is NOT "zero"- it is the set whose only member is 0.)

Quote:

Could someone please explain, why is it like this ?

- September 22nd 2013, 06:57 PMmrmaaza123Re: Arbitrary intersection of open sets
Could you please explain this in terms of neighborhoods of x?