# Math Help - metric spaces

1. ## metric spaces

Define a metric $d$ on a set $X$ having more than one element as follows:
For every $x,y \in X$, d(x,y)={1 if x =/= y, 0 if x = y}
Let $b$ in $X$. Give an example that shows the closure of B(b,1) =/= {y in Y : d(b,y)<=1}
NOTE: B(b,1) is an open ball centered at b with radius 1.

2. Originally Posted by dori1123
Define a metric $d$ on a set $X$ having more than one element as follows:
For every $x,y \in X$, d(x,y)={1 if x =/= y, 0 if x = y}
Let $b$ in $X$. Give an example that shows the closure of B(b,1) =/= {y in Y : d(b,y)<=1}
NOTE: B(b,1) is an open ball centered at b with radius 1.
By definition $B(b,1) = \{ x\in X | d(x,b) < 1 \} = X - \{ b \}$.
Now $B\left(b,\tfrac{1}{2}\right) = \{b\}$ does not intersect $X - \{ b\}$.
Thus, $\{b\}$ is not a boundary point.
Thus, $\overline{ B(b,1)} = X - \{b\}$.
Now, $\{x\in X: d(x,b)\leq 1\} = X$.

And we see that $X\not = X-\{b\}$.

3. Hello,