Find a non-abelian group whose proper subsets are all abelian.

Printable View

- Oct 7th 2011, 09:17 PMveronicak5678Abelian Subgroups
Find a non-abelian group whose proper subsets are all abelian.

- Oct 7th 2011, 09:30 PMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
which groups have you tried?

- Oct 7th 2011, 09:50 PMveronicak5678Re: Abelian Subgroups
S_3 , GLn

- Oct 7th 2011, 11:57 PMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
and what are your conclusions?

i presume you mean "subgroups" instead of "subsets", because "abelian set" makes no sense at all.... - Oct 8th 2011, 05:00 AMSwlabrRe: Abelian Subgroups
- Oct 8th 2011, 05:10 AMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
aw, i was rooting for you suggesting GL2(F2)....

- Oct 8th 2011, 05:57 AMSwlabrRe: Abelian Subgroups
- Oct 8th 2011, 06:42 AMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
um, did you not catch the joke i made?

- Oct 8th 2011, 10:56 AMDrexel28Re: Abelian Subgroups
Just a remark, is definitely a good choice, but why? It's a first-week-of-group-theory matter that every group of order at most five is abelian, thus if you can find a non-abelian group whose proper subgroups all have size at most five, then you're golden. But, clearly any group of order six has the property that every proper subgroup has order at most five, and so in particular, any non-abelian group of order six will have the property you seek. Ta-da, !

- Oct 8th 2011, 11:56 AMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
oh you're so cute when you're clever....

- Oct 8th 2011, 01:19 PMDrexel28Re: Abelian Subgroups
- Oct 10th 2011, 02:24 AMSwlabrRe: Abelian Subgroups
- Oct 10th 2011, 07:53 AMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
GL2(F2) is isomorphic to S3

- Oct 10th 2011, 07:58 AMSwlabrRe: Abelian Subgroups
- Oct 10th 2011, 08:21 AMDevenoRe: Abelian Subgroups
that's ok, i once proved was countable, which if correct, would surely have gained me a fields medal.