# Thread: Show that A and B are Communitative

1. ## Show that A and B are Communitative

I need some guidance on how to start answering this question please:

Question: Suppose C is a square matrix such that $\displaystyle c^2=I$. Let $\displaystyle CD_1C and B=CD_2C$ where $\displaystyle D_1$ and $\displaystyle D_2$ are diagonal Matrices. Show that A and B are communitative

2. Originally Posted by sparky
Question: Suppose C is a square matrix such that $\displaystyle c^2=I$. Let $\displaystyle CD_1C and B=CD_2C$ where $\displaystyle D_1$ and $\displaystyle D_2$ are diagonal Matrices. Show that A and B are communitative
I suppose you meant $\displaystyle A=CD_1C$ . Use $\displaystyle C^2=I$ and $\displaystyle D_1D_2=D_2D_1$

$\displaystyle AB=CD_1CCD_2C=CD_1C^2D_2C=\ldots$

$\displaystyle BA=\ldots$

Fernando Revilla

3. Yes you are right, Let A = CD1C, thanks

4. Originally Posted by FernandoRevilla
I suppose you meant $\displaystyle A=CD_1C$ . Use $\displaystyle C^2=I$ and $\displaystyle D_1D_2=D_2D_1$

$\displaystyle AB=CD_1CCD_2C=CD_1C^2D_2C=\ldots$

$\displaystyle BA=\ldots$

Fernando Revilla

Ok, is this correct?

$\displaystyle AB = CD_1CCD_2C$

$\displaystyle = CD_1C^2D_2C$

$\displaystyle = D_1C^4D_2$

$\displaystyle BA = CD_2CCD_1C$

$\displaystyle = CD_2C^2D_1C$

$\displaystyle = D_2C^4D_1$

$\displaystyle Therefore, AB = BA$

If this is correct, then what was the purpose of $\displaystyle C^2 = I$? To confuse me? What about the $\displaystyle D_1 and D_2$ being diagonal matrices - was that designed to confuse me as well? Or did they have some real purpose in this question?

5. Originally Posted by sparky

Ok, is this correct?

$\displaystyle AB = CD_1CCD_2C$

$\displaystyle = CD_1C^2D_2C$

$\displaystyle = D_1C^4D_2$

$\displaystyle BA = CD_2CCD_1C$

$\displaystyle = CD_2C^2D_1C$

$\displaystyle = D_2C^4D_1$

$\displaystyle Therefore, AB = BA$

If this is correct, then what was the purpose of $\displaystyle C^2 = I$? To confuse me? What about the $\displaystyle D_1 and D_2$ being diagonal matrices - was that designed to confuse me as well? Or did they have some real purpose in this question?
You aren't quite done yet. You know that C^2 = I, so therefore C^4 = I. Then we have that AB = D1D2 and BA = D2D1. What do you know about the matrices D1 and D2?

-Dan

6. I'm not sure how you went from line 2 to line 3, sparky. It looks like you're assuming that $\displaystyle C$commutes with $\displaystyle D_1$ and $\displaystyle D_2$, which you haven't proved (and which, without thinking too much about it, I doubt is true).

The facts that $\displaystyle C^2=I$ and the $\displaystyle D$'s are diagonal both play key roles in the proof. Can you show that $\displaystyle D_1D_2=D_2D_1$ as topsquark suggests?

7. Thanks for the reply Topsquark

What I know about D1 and D2 is that they are diagonal matrices, which means that they are square matrices with zeros outside of the diagonal entries, like this:

$\displaystyle $\begin{matrix} 1 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{matrix}$$

8. Originally Posted by sparky

What I know about D1 and D2 is that they are diagonal matrices, which means that they are square matrices with zeros outside of the diagonal entries, like this:

$\displaystyle $\begin{matrix} 1 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{matrix}$$
Right. Do two such matrices commute?

-Dan

9. Originally Posted by topsquark
Right. Do two such matrices commute?

-Dan
Ok, I was not sure, so to answer your question, I worked out a simple example (see below) and yes they do commute:

$\displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 2 \end{pmatrix}$$$\displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 3 & 0 \\ 0 & 4 \end{pmatrix}$ =\displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 3 & 0 \\ 0 & 8 \end{pmatrix}$ \displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 3 & 0 \\ 0 & 4 \end{pmatrix}$$$\displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 2 \end{pmatrix}$$

=$\displaystyle $\begin{pmatrix} 3 & 0 \\ 0 & 8 \end{pmatrix}$$

I think I now understand. Correct me if I'm wrong:

Since $\displaystyle C^2 = I$ and I is an identity matrix, therefore I is a diagonal matrix. C is also equal to I, therefore C is also diagonal. And since $\displaystyle D_1$ and $\displaystyle D_2$ are also diagonal, therefore since all of them are diagonal, AB = BA

11. Originally Posted by sparky

I think I now understand. Correct me if I'm wrong:

Since $\displaystyle C^2 = I$ and I is an identity matrix, therefore I is a diagonal matrix. C is also equal to I, therefore C is also diagonal. And since $\displaystyle D_1$ and $\displaystyle D_2$ are also diagonal, therefore since all of them are diagonal, AB = BA
Hmmmm... If C = -I would this still work? You don't need this anyway.
$\displaystyle AB = C D_1 C C D_2 C = C D_1 C^2 D_2 C = C D_1 I D_2 C = C D_1 D_2 C$

Do this for BA. What do you get?

-Dan

12. Ok,

$\displaystyle BA=CD_2CCD_1C$

$\displaystyle BA=CD_2C^2D_1C$

$\displaystyle BA=CD_2ID_1C$

$\displaystyle BA=CD_2D_1C$

which is the same thing as $\displaystyle AB=CD_1D_2C$

Thanks!

13. Originally Posted by sparky

Ok, is this correct?

$\displaystyle AB = CD_1CCD_2C$

$\displaystyle = CD_1C^2D_2C$

$\displaystyle = D_1C^4D_2$
Where did you get this? How did the "C"s from the sides move inside? Better to use $\displaystyle C^2= I$ here and write
$\displaystyle = CD_1C_2C$.

$\displaystyle BA = CD_2CCD_1C$

$\displaystyle = CD_2C^2D_1C$

$\displaystyle = D_2C^4D_1$
same thing: $\displaystyle = CD_2D_1C$ and, since $\displaystyle D_2$ and $\displaystyle D_1$ are diagonal matrices they commute: this is the same as $\displaystyle CD_1D_2C$ that you had before.

$\displaystyle Therefore, AB = BA$

If this is correct, then what was the purpose of $\displaystyle C^2 = I$? To confuse me? What about the $\displaystyle D_1 and D_2$ being diagonal matrices - was that designed to confuse me as well? Or did they have some real purpose in this question?

14. Thanks a lot HallsofIvy