Let V be vector space with dim(V)=n. And let U,W be subspaces with n-1 dimension each,I need to prove that: U+W=V if and only if U!=W

Thank you all!

Printable View

- Dec 2nd 2009, 12:05 PMAlso sprach ZarathustraSubspaces and Dimension
**Let V be vector space with dim(V)=n. And let U,W be subspaces with n-1 dimension each,I need to prove that****: U+W=V if and only if U!=W**

Thank you all! - Dec 2nd 2009, 01:10 PMDefunkt
I'll assume you know how to prove that if $\displaystyle U+W=V$ then $\displaystyle U\neq W$ (it is trivial).

Assume U,W are subspaces of V with $\displaystyle dim V = n, ~ dimU = dim W = n-1$ such that $\displaystyle U \neq W$.

Let $\displaystyle B = \{w_1,w_2,...,w_{n-1}\}$ be a basis for W.

Let $\displaystyle u \in U - W ~ \text{s.t.} ~ u \neq 0$ (we know one such element exists otherwise $\displaystyle U=W$ since $\displaystyle 0\in U, ~ 0 \in W$).

Then u is not spanned by $\displaystyle \{w_1,w_2,...,w_{n-1}\}$, otherwise it would be an element of W (by definition). Then, $\displaystyle B' = \{w_1,w_2,...,w_{n-1},u\}$ is an independent set and obviously $\displaystyle dim B' = n$ and therefore it is a basis of V.

This gives us that $\displaystyle V \subset U+W$.

However, obviously there can be no element in $\displaystyle U+W$ that is not in V since they are subspaces, therefore $\displaystyle U+W \subset V \rightarrow U+W = V$

By the way, what uni are you studying in? - Dec 2nd 2009, 01:22 PMAlso sprach Zarathustra
Thanks a lot! But, your assumption is wrong, can you prove the first line please?

- Dec 2nd 2009, 01:24 PMDefunkt
Well, assume $\displaystyle U+W=V$. Assume, by contradiction, that $\displaystyle U = W$. Then $\displaystyle U+W = U = W = V$

What does this give us? (hint: look at the dimensions) - Dec 2nd 2009, 01:33 PMAlso sprach Zarathustra
That the dimension of U and W is not the dimension of V. Paradox?

I am really bad at it! Thank you for your patients! - Dec 2nd 2009, 01:37 PMDefunkt
Yes, that is correct! since $\displaystyle U+W=V$, we must have that $\displaystyle dim(U+W) = dim(V)$ but in this case $\displaystyle dim(U+W)=n-1$, $\displaystyle dim(V)=n$ therefore we reach a contradiction, and then $\displaystyle U \neq W$.